One of my aunts that "cared for my soul" asked me that one time...... "Donovan, have you accepted Jesus Christ as your Lord and Savior, and asked Him to forgive you of all of your sins??" I, at the time, was a mere lad of 19 or 20, and I looked her straight in the eye and replied, "Aunt Ruth, I'm glad you care so much, but I haven't even started to sin yet." She got a confused look on her face, and started to cry and ran off to my mom. My dad overheard the whole thing and just about passed out he was laughing so hard.
I highly recommend you try it again using my tact.
Or extreme lack thereof.