Cars over at the shop, they did their estimate and it came out to about $1400 higher, to $4400'ish.
Geico approved it and payed out to the shop for the deposit. Parts are on order.
I'm mildly surprised they didn't total it. KBB says the car isn't worth more than $4500 or so. Guess we just squeaked by.
Totalling a car that has a low value sucks. I have an '06 Scion xB and if it got totalled there would be no way for me to find another one in the same condition for it's KBB value. or any car in the same condition.