Debate thread: Are people born good or evil

I tend to agree with FG, "Evil" is a matter of perspective.

Ask a hardcore southern baptist if smoking pot is "evil" and they will no doubt say yes. Most of us would probably say pot, who cares. No biggie, probably not good for you but inherently evil.

Or from another angle, Dr. Evil thinks launching a nuclear warhead into the earth's core thus flooding every city on the planet with liquid hot magma is just fine and dandy, but the United Nations might think otherwise.

It's all a matter of perspective.

Once you know what we are considering evil as, then you can determine if some level of it is genetic/physiological or what part of it is learned behavior.

I personally think it is a combination of the 2. I think hormones and brain structure is a factor, but probably if you grow up abused and beaten you'll be an angry person too thus making you more prone to doing bad things.
 
Last edited:
I would put forth that both options are equally viable.

Johnny grows up in a healthy, stable family environment. He is given love, structure and education in equal portions. His parents do their best to teach him right from wrong, and yet as an adult he has an extensive dead hooker collection buried in the backyard.

Billy grows up in a 'broken' household, spending the first 18 years of his life exposed to violence, degradation, etc. Billy and Johnny get together once a week to discuss hooker dismemberment practices.

I think that some people are just born bad, but I also think that a bad environment can turn just about anyone.
 
This is funny, I just went to a Buddhist center last night and the discussion was on this very topic. The teacher said that living creatures are good. And that if you spend enough time with someone you will find at least 5 good qualities in that person (he said some people take longer than others) but the qualities are there because they have to be.
 
This is funny, I just went to a Buddhist center last night and the discussion was on this very topic. The teacher said that living creatures are good. And that if you spend enough time with someone you will find at least 5 good qualities in that person (he said some people take longer than others) but the qualities are there because they have to be.

Oooh how did that go last night? Sounds enlightening. I wonder if Zac will go with me. hmmms
 
I would put forth that both options are equally viable.

Johnny grows up in a healthy, stable family environment. He is given love, structure and education in equal portions. His parents do their best to teach him right from wrong, and yet as an adult he has an extensive dead hooker collection buried in the backyard.

Billy grows up in a 'broken' household, spending the first 18 years of his life exposed to violence, degradation, etc. Billy and Johnny get together once a week to discuss hooker dismemberment practices.

I think that some people are just born bad, but I also think that a bad environment can turn just about anyone.