while meat pies are usually delicious, they are not my favorite thing. If I had to pick a meat-based pie that was not a "pot-pie" it would be shepherd's pie. I do love a good turkey pot pie though. 
I think either french silk, coconut or banana cream, or apple would come in as a tie in the non-meat pie category.

I think either french silk, coconut or banana cream, or apple would come in as a tie in the non-meat pie category.